think tank forum

technology » best 3 TB hdd

lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
hitachi deskstar

wdc caviar green

seagate barracuda xt

toshiba/fujitsu, samsung -- no 3TB offering
Carpetsmoker's avatar
13 years ago
link
Carpetsmoker
Martin
What's the deal with the PCIe card for the WD drives ... ?
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
r1, link
lucas
i ❤ demo
link

maybe it has to do with capacity and sata specification. the manual in the photo says "2.5/3 TB Hard Drives SATA Host Bus Adapter". upon inspection, the card is specified as sata III. maybe there's an interoperability issue at capacities >2 TB due when using sata II. just a guess!
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
i wouldn't mind some of those cards. although i'm running out of room in which to put hard drives in my case.
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
the wd spins at 5400 rpm. too slow.

the seagate and hitachi are about the same in terms of performance. the hitatchi is better at random operations, and the seagate is better at contiguous operations.

i can't source the seagate. i guess i'll buy the hitachi.
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
they both now have enterprise versions available.

hitatchi

ultrastar (enterprise, 1:10^15 error rate, MTBF 2 Mh) for $350
deskstar (consumer, 1:10^14 error rate, MTBF unknown) for $175

seagate

constellation es.2 (enterprise, 1:10^15 error rate, MTBF 1.2 Mh), price unknown
barracuda xt (consumer, 1:10^14 error rate, MTBF unknown), price unknown
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
should i do RAID-1 with three consumer disks or RAID-1 with two enterprise disks?

--

chance of data loss for RAID-1 with three consumer disks: 1:10^42

chance of data loss for RAID-1 with two enterprise disks: 1:10^30

--

three consumer disks is less expensive than two enterprise disks. it will be faster. in the event of a single disk failure, redundancy is maintained. however, having an extra disk will be louder and consume more power.
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
oops, i bought the wrong disks.

i think i wanted 3 TB disks.

:[
Carpetsmoker's avatar
13 years ago
link
Carpetsmoker
Martin
> having an extra disk will be louder and consume more power.

In general, consumer disks are less noisy. For example my old WD RE 500GB drives made a hell of a lot of noise compared to my WD 1.5TB GP drives.
Also, typical power usage in in the <5W range, I wouldn't worry about it.
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
disklabel doesn't appreciate 3 TB HDDs.

i hope this was the correct way to use the disks:

gmirror label -vb round-robin gm0 /dev/ada4 /dev/ada5
gpart create -s GPT /dev/mirror/gm0
gpart add -t freebsd-ufs mirror/gm0
newfs -U /dev/mirror/gm0p1
lucas's avatar
13 years ago
link
lucas
i ❤ demo
> In general, consumer disks are less noisy.

BTW, I bought two 3 TB Ultrastar disks.